New York has no shortage of Italian restaurants, but Sistina NYC has something that feels increasingly rare: the kind of old-school elegance that makes dinner feel like an actual occasion.
Located at 24 East 81st Street on the Upper East Side, Sistina is an upscale Italian restaurant in a townhouse setting, with a dining room filled with artwork, white-tablecloth tables and an atmosphere that encourages diners to settle in rather than sprint through a meal. Sistina
The restaurant is led by Chef and owner Giuseppe Bruno, and the menu leans into classic Italian cooking with plenty of luxurious touches. Current offerings include tuna tartare, burrata and beets, crispy artichokes, vitello tonnato and beef carpaccio with black truffle.
Then there is the pasta.
Pappardelle Sistina, with veal Bolognese and wild mushrooms, shares the menu with cacio e pepe, bucatini all’Amatriciana, linguine with clams and mussels, gnocchi and seasonal specialties. There is also fettuccine with black truffles and crab for anyone who believes pasta should occasionally have a little more drama.
Sistina’s dessert menu refuses to be ignored, either. Tiramisu, profiteroles, a chocolate-and-vanilla gelato tartufo and housemade gelati and sorbetti round things out. The tiramisu even gets a distinctive touch with Strega-liquor caviar.
And for Midtown’s downtown friends who think the Upper East Side is too far away, there is a compelling reason to make the trip: Sistina’s $45 three-course weekday lunch offers a more accessible way to experience the restaurant’s Italian cooking.
The restaurant also features a second-floor lounge, private dining spaces and a garden room designed for intimate gatherings and larger events.
For anyone searching for Sistina NYC, Upper East Side Italian restaurants, fine dining NYC or Italian restaurants near the Met, this is an address worth knowing.
Because sometimes dinner isn’t just dinner.
Sometimes it deserves a townhouse, truffles and tiramisu.