New York restaurant prices have changed a little since 2006. Actually, “a little” may be the understatement of the century. So when Benjamin Steakhouse celebrates its 20th anniversary on October 6, the Midtown institution is doing something almost unheard of in 2026: bringing back its original menu at its original 2006 prices.
For one day only, diners can return to the restaurant’s opening-era menu at 52 East 41st Street and experience what a Benjamin steak dinner cost two decades ago. And judging by today’s prices, the savings are enough to make your wallet order dessert.
Take the rib eye. On October 6, it will be just $40.95, compared with the current $96.95 price. The filet mignon will be $41.95 instead of $84.95, while the Chilean sea bass drops to $32.95 from $60.95. Even the jumbo lump crab cakes are going back to their original $13.95 price, compared with $31.95 today.
And then there is the steakhouse classic: porterhouse for two, returning to its 2006 price of $82.95. That’s considerably easier to swallow than its current $160.95 price tag.
The promotion is more than a discount, though. Benjamin Steakhouse is essentially turning back the clock to when it first opened its doors in Midtown, offering longtime customers a nostalgic trip—and giving newer diners a chance to experience the restaurant’s original menu exactly as it was intended.
Benjamin has built its reputation around USDA Prime steaks, dry-aging, classic steakhouse sides and old-school New York service, all of which remain central to the restaurant today. Its current menu still features dry-aged porterhouse, rib eye, New York sirloin and filet mignon.
For anyone searching Benjamin Steakhouse 20th anniversary, Benjamin Steakhouse October 6, 2006 prices, NYC steakhouse deals or Benjamin Steakhouse original menu, this is one date worth circling.
Because New York rarely gives you a chance to eat like it’s 2006.
And even more rarely lets you pay like it.