New York has no shortage of great sandwiches, but every once in a while, something comes along that makes the usual pastrami on rye look a little predictable. Enter Macario, a Mexican lonchería introducing New Yorkers to one of Guadalajara’s most beloved street-food traditions: the legendary lonche bañado.
And trust us, this is not a sandwich you want to eat in a white shirt.
Founded by Guadalajara native Marshall Dean, Macario was created to bring an authentic taste of Jalisco to New York City. The restaurant specializes in lonches bañados, a regional Mexican sandwich dating back to the 1950s that features savory fillings tucked inside toasted birote bread before being generously covered in a warm, slightly spicy tomato-based sauce.
Think of it as a sandwich that decided ordinary condiments simply weren’t enough.
The bread is particularly important. Macario uses custom-baked birote, a traditional Mexican sourdough roll with a crisp crust and chewy interior, made fresh each morning. Inside, diners can choose from slow-cooked pulled pork, tender chicken or traditional Mexican panela cheese, all finished with the restaurant’s signature house-made sauce and crema.
For those who prefer their sandwiches a little crispier, there’s also the Prensado. This modern Macario creation presses the sauce inside the bread alongside melted cheese before grilling everything to achieve an irresistible crispy exterior and gooey center.
And if that’s not enough, the menu also features loaded Mad Nachos, Guadalajara-style guacamole, quesadillas and other Mexican comfort-food favorites.
After building a following in Park Slope, Macario is bringing its Guadalajara-inspired sandwich concept to Manhattan’s East Village, introducing even more New Yorkers to this relatively undiscovered Mexican specialty.
Our verdict: Forget your usual sandwich routine. Macario is serving up saucy, slow-cooked, flavor-packed Mexican comfort food that requires plenty of napkins and absolutely zero table manners. Sometimes the messier the meal, the better the experience.