Who needs a traditional Thanksgiving dinner when you can squeeze the entire holiday onto a sandwich? Edith’s Sandwich Counter in Brooklyn is bringing back one of its most beloved seasonal creations, and it’s every bit as indulgent as it sounds.
Meet The Carmela, a Thanksgiving-inspired sandwich that has become something of an annual tradition at Edith’s. Now returning for its fourth consecutive year, this over-the-top creation is giving New Yorkers another reason to be thankful for sandwich season.
So what’s inside? House-smoked turkey takes center stage, layered with tangy cranberry Dijon, a slightly spicy creamed spinach aioli and herby stuffing panisse. It’s essentially Thanksgiving dinner reimagined between two slices of bread, minus the awkward family conversations and the three-hour wait for the turkey to finish cooking.
The combination is particularly clever. The cranberry Dijon brings a sweet-and-tangy punch, while the creamed spinach aioli adds richness and a little heat. The smoked turkey delivers the holiday familiarity, and the stuffing panisse provides a deliciously unexpected twist on traditional stuffing.
It’s the kind of sandwich that makes you question why Thanksgiving only happens once a year.
Clearly, Edith’s customers agree. The restaurant says the Carmela has developed an enthusiastic following over its previous appearances, with demand continuing to grow year after year.
The good news? This seasonal superstar is sticking around until the week before Christmas, giving Brooklyn food lovers plenty of time to get their hands on one. The less encouraging news? Given its popularity, waiting too long might mean missing out.
Whether you’re a devoted Edith’s regular or simply searching for the best Thanksgiving sandwich in NYC, the Carmela deserves a spot on your must-try list.
Our verdict: Turkey, cranberry, stuffing and spinach aioli? Thanksgiving just got a serious upgrade. And honestly, we wouldn’t mind if this holiday sandwich became a permanent menu fixture.