Butterfish Sushi Is the North Jersey Omakase Spot NYC Foodies Should Know

Sometimes it's just one train ride away.
1 Min Read 0 133

New York may get most of the attention when it comes to serious sushi, but cross the Hudson and there is a Rutherford restaurant quietly making a case for North Jersey sushi. Enter Butterfish Sushi, the intimate Japanese restaurant at 15 Franklin Place that has built a following around high-end omakase, premium fish and a decidedly un-stuffy approach to fine dining.

The concept is straightforward: take exceptional ingredients, treat them carefully and let the sushi do most of the talking. Butterfish’s menu includes both curated tasting experiences and à la carte nigiri, giving diners the option to go all-in on omakase or build their own sushi adventure.

And the ingredient list gets serious.

The restaurant’s current offerings include Bluefin tuna flown from Japan six days a week, Hokkaido uni, Japanese A5 Wagyu, botan ebi, hamachi, madai and kinmedai. There are also more playful combinations, including nigiri finished with house-made chili crunch, yuzu koshu and other unexpected accents.

One of the more intriguing options is The One, a curated sushi experience that combines sashimi, nigiri and hand rolls. For diners who prefer the chef to make the difficult decisions, it is essentially the sushi equivalent of saying, “You pick—I trust you.”

Butterfish has also earned attention for its hospitality. General Manager Jojo Sammut has discussed the restaurant’s rapid rise and its plans to expand the concept, including a hand-roll-focused spinoff.

The result is a destination that feels more ambitious than your average neighborhood sushi restaurant while remaining approachable enough for diners who don’t necessarily want a three-hour ceremony.

For anyone searching for Butterfish Sushi, Rutherford NJ restaurants, best sushi in New Jersey, North Jersey omakase or premium sushi near NYC, this is one to keep on the radar.

Because sometimes the best sushi night isn’t across the river.

Sometimes it’s just one train ride away.

Editor

As Editor of NYMatinee.com, we cover the best of New York City—from buzzy restaurants and hidden bars to nightlife, culture, events and everything worth knowing. I’m always hunting for the next great opening, hottest reservation and most unexpected NYC experience, bringing readers sharp, witty and insider-focused stories they’ll actually want to read. Email - editor@nymatinee.com